I will admit that I'm one of "those."
"Those people" that consider themselves to be socially aware, and
environmentally conscious-especially when it directly affects me. It would be
nice to think that I'm conscious about the greater good, and while I try (my oh
my does 'she upstairs' know how I try) to work for the greater good, it's hard.
I remember when I started making attempts, or my first baby steps as I like to
consider that time to becoming more environmentally conscious. I couldn't get
the Prius- for one, I don't drive; and I just couldn't jive with low pressured
water (I need it to be skin breaking strong). I started with my personal
products, small yes, but after all If I can't make the change for that which I
directly absorb, how could I start to think about ways of greater environmental
impact? Yes, I changed my face wash in order to think about ways of changing
systems of operation for the environment. I was on a mission!
I don't use a lot. Some face wash, shampoo, and
some eye cream that has now come in handy as a grad school self-care attempt.
While I have come to consider the products I use to be "safe" and
"environmentally friendly" since I buy them at environmentally conscious
places like Whole Foods and Rainbow Grocery -I'd be surprised to see how they
fare, especially since their whole goal is to "clarify" and
"purify" my life. Let's take a look:
Neutrogena Naturals; Purifying Pore Scrub
While the product works to "gently
[scrub] away impurities that can build up in pores to improve complexion for
fresh clear skin," I wonder what else besides the promoted willowbark,
bio-nutrients, and jojoba bead scrub, is in this wash...not to mention, what in
the world is "bio-nutrients?!"The Brand does a good job at labeling
its ingredients, even providing its alleged source for the material. With
ingredients like: glycerin, hydrogenated castor oil, cocamidopropyl betaine,
xanthin gum, guar hydroxpropyltrimonium, sodium benzoate, and fragrance. After
doing some research on some of four of the ingredients that are giving me some
concern here is what I found:
Guar Hydroxpropyltrimonium: Guar hydroxypropyltrimonium chloride is a water-soluble,
organic compound that is a "quaternary ammonium derivative of guar
(cluster beans), what this means to my face is that it is a substance whose
chemical structure has four "carbon groups attached to a positively
charged nitrogen atom." While plant derived, there is a synthetic portion
to it. In terms of its safety on skin and hair (for which it is a very good
softening agent). With an EWG (Environmental Working Group) score of 1 and a
rating of "good" from Paula’s Choice, guar hydroxypropyltrimonium
chloride is deemed to be very safe, a non-irritant, and is biodegradable.
Score!
Cocamidopropyl Betaine: While the package says "coconut derived" which sounds
great because I love coconut ANYTHING, but of course some Googling led me to find that CB is a
synthetic surfactant, where surfactant is more so a wetting agent than anything
else, sad. CB as used in products has been associated with irritation and
allergic contact dermatitis, reactions that could be due to the ingredient
itself or to impurities present in its compound, such as 3-dimethylaminopropylamine,
which apparently is nothing but a colorless binding agent with a fishy oder-
not good. EWG gave it a score of 4, which allows it to fall in the
"good" category, but the fact that the chemical itself causes
irritation leads me to think that this could maybe be one of the reasons why my
face is a little red after using.
Xanthan Gum: XG is a polysaccharide, a sugar-based polymer produced by bacteria (great); it is used as a
viscosity agent for personal care products. Some research into its EWG scoring
shows that the agent itself has a low rating in regards to its hazardousness on
the body-giving it a rating of "fair," as an ingredient in products.
I beginning to have second thoughts about this product.Fragrance: While my research on what the actual "fragrance" of
this product was (and yes, I smelled and tried to guess) what I found through
EWG (an incredible source!) was that fragrance in the product is cause for some
concern because of connections to allergies/immunotoxicity, irritation (skin,
eyes, or lungs), and organ system toxicity (non-reproductive).While I have come to love this product because of how
smooth my skin feels afterwards, and how clean it looks post use, I have to
admit that even though EWG gives it a score of 3, putting it into a
"low" category in regards to potential harm, the limited available
data on the ingredients and its overall effects on the body is leaving feeling
a little insecure as to whether I want to continue with this or not. While
Neutrogena may be "dermatologist recommended" I might have to take a
pass and move on from this one.
Source for Information: LINK
Juice Beauty; Smoothing Eye Concentrate
This has by far become my new best friend. Long nights studying and reviewing best practices for health services has left a mark on my face, in fact two dark circles that make me look like a very tired and knowledgable raccoon. While I am proud in my accomplishment of acquiring new information on care services and best practice models I don't this new feature (the circles) to become permanent. While a good nights rest is ideal, right now, in this moment its more of a dream than a reality (there is just so much to knowledge to gain and so little time). I did a search my new friend, almost like the way you stalk a guy that you're going to go on a date with. Here is what I uncovered:
It is hard to believe that so much
comes in just .5fl oz, but apparently the old saying "big things come in
small packages" holds true. The concentrate contains the following
ingredients: organic white grape juice, organic aloe, vegetable
glycerin, vegetable oil, cetearyl alcohol & glucoside, organic jojoba seed
oil, organic sunflower seed oil, organic avocado oil, cetearyl olivate,
sorbitan olivate, gluconolactone, sodium benzoate, behenyl alcohol,
organic evening primrose oil, organic linseed oil, organic borage seed oil,
meadowfoam seed oil, tocopherol, hesperidin methyl chalcone, dipeptide-2,
palmitoyl tetra peptide-3, xanthan gum, steareth-20, carrot seed oil,
extracts of cucumber, green tea leaf, algae, honeysuckle flower, and Japanese
honeysuckle, vitamin K1, panthenol, vitamin C, hesperidin, ethylhexylglycerin,
tetrasodium glutamate diacetate, sodium hydroxide, and sweet orange
essential oil.According to The Beauty Proof, an incredible site that provides
information and access to natural beauty products, the ingredients for the eye
concentrate range on their Scale of Safety in the "extremely safe" to "reasonably
safe." Considering that only three of the ingredients fell into the
"reasonably safe" range I decided to take a closer look at the make
up of the ingredients to figure out why.
Sodium Benzoate: SB, a synthetic chemical that is produced when
benzoic acid (found naturally in some fruits and spices) is combined
with sodium hydroxide. Since SB contains a natural ingredient, it
is probably safe, right? While I would like to think this, I have to correct myself. While the FDA, has labeled this chemical as "acceptable" when consumed in low amounts since SB is already present in low levels in berries,
apples, plums, cinnamon, and several other natural foods. There’s nothing scary
about the chemical in these items, after all natural is the key word. But lab-synthesized SB (and its
cousin benzoic acid) are a different story, especially since apples and cinnamon sticks are not listed ingredients in the eye concentrate. It is noted that manufacturers add SB to health and beauty products such as mouthwash, shampoo, body
lotions, and deodorant to prevent bacteria from contaminating these
items. (a major thank you to them) Over-the-counter and prescription drugs such as pills, cough
syrups, and topical medications also can contain sodium benzoate as a prevention method. While not ideal, considering that the product is going very near my eye (since its organic it is actually safe to use on the upper and lower lids of the eye) it is nice to know that the manufactures of Juice Beauty products are using bacteria fighting agents to keep the concentrate fresh. (Source: LINK)
Steareth-20:Steareth-20 is a synthetic polymer composed
of PEG (polyethylene glycol) and stearyl alcohol, which is used reduce the tendency of finished products to generate foam when shaken
(as I am recommended to do every time I use the cream). When used in the
formulation of skin care products like eye cream, Stearyl Alcohol acts as a
lubricant on the skin surface, which gives the skin a soft, smooth appearance. Due to the presence of PEG, this ingredient may contain potentially
toxic manufacturing impurities such as 1,4-dioxane. Dioxane, is considered to
be many things. While some would consider it less harmful than table salt, the
US Department of Health and Human Service reported that dioxane (any number) is
classified by the National Toxicology Program as "reasonably anticipated
to be a human carcinogen.” What does this means to my eye cream? Further
research concluded that in regards to its use in cosmetics and other body
products, dioxane is used as a byproduct of the ethoxylation process (a process that is found in many moisturizing products). The
ethoxylation process makes the cleansing agents found in the moisturizers less
abrasive and offers enhanced foaming characteristics, which is good when taking
into account that it is being used on the eye lid where the skin layers are
thin. 1,4-Dioxane overall has been found in small amounts in cosmetics and
moisturizing products (like the eye cream), while not encouraged in regards to
their use, it is not heavily regulated by the government. How do I feel about
this? A little scared, but not entirely perturbed when I read other health
reviews on the cream and each one labeled the day and night cream as “safe to
use.”(Source: LINK)
Sodium Hydroxide:Sodium Hydroxide is an
inorganic compound used to control the pH levels (power of hydrogen) or serve
as a buffering agent in many cosmetics and body products like lotion, shampoo,
conditioner, hair gels, and other moisturizers. SH has been approved by the FDA,
and has received the GRAS (Generally Recognized as Safe) rating as a direct
food additive, that is safe to use in products and in fact is also used for washing
produce before delivery to the grocery stores. Although SH has
been linked to cancer, specifically of the esophagus, it is only after the SH
was directly consumed and since I have no plans on drinking my eye cream, I
think that my esophagus will be fine.(Source: LINK)
Overall the three ingredients in question do not raise that much concern to me, especially since the ingredients in question only cause major harm to the body when consumed or absorbed in large amounts on a regular basis. While the company prides itself on being "the organic solution," it is understandable that they would use some non-organic organic products in order to keep the moisturizer fresh, and manageable for application. Therefore, I think I will definitely keep using.
Source of Information: LINK